Disclaimer: The following article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal or financial advice. Laws regarding…
Contents
show
Disclaimer: The following article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal or financial advice. Laws regarding trustee compensation in Queensland can vary depending on the trust deed, relevant statutes, and case law. If you serve as a trustee or plan to create a trust with compensated trustees, consult a qualified solicitor to ensure compliance with current regulations and to protect both trustees and beneficiaries.
Trustees in Queensland shoulder significant responsibilities, from prudently managing assets and safeguarding beneficiaries’ interests to adhering strictly to the trust deed and fiduciary obligations. Often, individuals serving as trustees wonder if they can receive payment for their time and efforts. While Queensland’s Trusts Act 1973 and common law provide general guidance, trust deeds typically govern compensation specifics. Below, we explore why trustees seek remuneration, the legal conditions under which it’s permissible, and best practices for ensuring clear, dispute-free compensation arrangements.
The Rationale for Trustee Compensation
- Time and Expertise
Acting as a trustee might involve heavy administrative tasks—filing tax returns, managing property, investing funds, distributing income—which can demand professional skill or considerable time. - Professional Trustees
Corporate or professional trustees, such as accountants or solicitors, often expect fees for their services, akin to providing a fiduciary “business” function. - Fairness to Non-Beneficiary Trustees
If the trustee is not an estate beneficiary or caretaker themselves, but invests significant labor, many believe they should be compensated to avoid an unfair burden.
Legal Framework in Queensland
Trust Deed Provisions
The trust deed typically reigns supreme. If it explicitly authorises trustee remuneration—outlining how fees are calculated or drawn—this generally governs. Courts will usually uphold that clause unless it breaches public policy or the trustee is found to be acting dishonestly.
Statutory Support: Trusts Act 1973 (Qld)
Although the Trusts Act 1973 does not automatically grant compensation rights to trustees, certain sections let courts:
- Approve or fix the compensation if the deed is silent.
- Authorize additional remuneration if extraordinary tasks or litigation burden the trustee beyond normal scope.
Common Law and Equity Principles
Historically, trustees undertook their roles gratuitously, receiving only out-of-pocket reimbursements unless the deed allowed fees. Modern practice acknowledges trustees can charge a reasonable fee if:
- No conflict of interest arises.
- Beneficiaries consent, or
- A court order sanctions such compensation.
Methods of Trustee Compensation
Below is a table summarising how trustees commonly structure compensation:
| Method | Description | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed Annual Fee | A set sum per year or period, often used by professional or corporate trustees. | Predictable cost for the trust. | Might not reflect actual workload if tasks fluctuate significantly. |
| Commission on Income/Capital | Trustee takes a percentage of trust income or gains, sometimes also a portion upon distribution. | Aligns trustee’s remuneration with trust performance. | Might cause tension if the percentage feels too high for beneficiaries. |
| Hourly Rate | Trustee logs actual hours spent managing the trust, billing at a set rate. | Transparent for active trusts. | Requires detailed timekeeping; beneficiaries may question certain hours billed. |
| Deed-Determined Formula | The trust deed specifically states how to calculate trustee remuneration, perhaps referencing a professional fee schedule. | Minimizes confusion if well-defined. | Can be inflexible if unforeseen complexities arise or if the trust’s scope changes drastically. |
Note: If the deed is silent, trustees often rely on beneficiary consensus or a court application to approve a method of compensation.
Reimbursements vs. Compensation
Reimbursement of Expenses
All trustees, paid or unpaid, can reclaim reasonable out-of-pocket costs directly related to trust administration:
- Filing fees, legal advice costs, accounting services.
- Postage, travel for trust business, property maintenance bills.
Such reimbursements differ from profit or “compensation” in that they merely keep the trustee from incurring personal losses. They are typically uncontroversial unless the trustee’s claims appear excessive or unrelated.
Earning a Profit
“Compensation” or “remuneration” implies the trustee receives something beyond cost recovery, effectively a profit or wage for their services. This requires either:
- Explicit authority in the trust deed or
- Consent from all beneficiaries (all being adults and with absolute entitlements) or
- Court order if no deed clause or beneficiary consensus emerges.
Without such authorisation, a trustee who unilaterally takes fees may breach fiduciary duty.
Factors Influencing Trustee Compensation Amount
Complexity of Assets
A trust holding multiple properties, share portfolios, or overseas holdings demands more time and professional skill. The trustee’s compensation might be higher to reflect the estate’s complexities.
Ongoing or Short-Term Administration
- Long-term discretionary trusts or special disability trusts can run for decades, requiring continuous management and annual reporting—justifying ongoing fees.
- Short-term wind-up tasks might only justify a single payment or small commission at distribution.
Beneficiary Relations
If all beneficiaries are aligned in trusting the trustee, they may readily approve a compensation plan or accept a negotiated commission. In litigious families, the trustee might require a court order to avoid disputes over perceived overcharging.
Potential Disputes Over Trustee Compensation
Beneficiary Objections
Beneficiaries might argue:
- The fee is excessive relative to the trust’s size.
- The trustee performed minimal tasks but claims a high percentage of income.
- The trustee never obtained formal approval for charging fees absent a deed clause.
Breach of Duty Allegations
If a trustee unilaterally withholds fees from the trust without disclosure, beneficiaries could claim breach of fiduciary duty. The trustee might face removal or have to repay any unauthorised amounts.
Court Resolution
If negotiations fail, beneficiaries can apply to the Supreme Court of Queensland for an order adjusting or disallowing trustee fees. The court weighs the trust deed’s wording, the trustee’s workload, results, and reasonableness.
Best Practices for Trustees in Queensland
| Practice | Benefit |
|---|---|
| Check the Trust Deed | If it explicitly authorises fees and the formula, follow it strictly. |
| Obtain Consent / Agreement | If the deed is silent, seek unanimous adult beneficiary consent or apply to court for an order. |
| Keep Detailed Records | Transparent accounting fosters beneficiary confidence. Document hours, tasks performed, and expenses. |
| Avoid Overreaching | Request a fair rate or formula. Excessive fees risk beneficiary backlash or court scrutiny. |
| Annual / Periodic Reporting | Summaries of trust income, expenses, and trustee fees keep all parties informed and reduce suspicion. |
| Consult Professional Advisors | If complex tasks arise, engaging accountants or solicitors ensures correct approach. Don’t try to do it all alone if unskilled. |
Example: Trustee Fee Clause in a QLD Family Trust
Scenario: The Brown Family Trust deed states:
“The trustee is entitled to a reasonable annual fee of 1% of the net trust assets under management, plus reimbursement of expenses.”
After the trust is settled, the trustee invests assets responsibly, collecting 1% each year for ongoing management. Beneficiaries see annual statements showing how the trustee calculates the fee. No disputes arise, as the deed’s clarity fosters acceptance.
Lesson: Clear, upfront provisions reduce friction. Because the trust deed sets the rate and the trustee accounts for it openly, the arrangement runs smoothly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Must trustees always charge a fee in Queensland?
No. Many family or friend trustees serve gratis, claiming only expense reimbursements. Charging a fee is optional unless the trust deed or the beneficiaries direct it.
Q2: Do corporate trustees automatically get paid?
Typically, yes, corporate trustees have set fee schedules. However, the deed or a separate service agreement should confirm the structure. Beneficiaries can challenge fees if deemed unreasonably high.
Q3: How do I adjust the trustee’s fee if the trust deed sets a fixed rate but the trust’s scope changes?
You can negotiate with beneficiaries to vary the deed or apply to the Supreme Court if all parties cannot agree. The court can revise the rate to reflect current circumstances.
Q4: Do testamentary trusts in wills allow trustee fees?
Often the will’s testamentary trust clause states how trustees are compensated (or if they serve for free). If silent, the trustee might ask the beneficiaries or the court for a fair allowance.
Q5: Is trustee compensation taxed as personal income?
Yes, trustee fees are usually considered assessable income for the trustee. Consult a tax advisor about reporting the fee on the trustee’s personal or entity returns.
Key Takeaways & Summary
- Trustee Compensation in Queensland is generally permissible if the trust deed authorises it or if beneficiaries/court approve.
- Method of Payment: Could be a fixed fee, commission on income/capital, or an hourly rate. The trustee must ensure it’s fair and disclosed.
- Potential Conflicts: Beneficiaries may challenge fees as excessive or unauthorized. Good practice is transparency and rigorous accounting.
- No Deed Clause? Seek beneficiary consent if they’re all adults with vested interests or apply to the Supreme Court for an order.
- Professional Advice: Trustees with complex duties or large assets often rely on accountants or solicitors to avoid missteps and justify fees.
By adhering to these best practices and ensuring the trust deed or beneficiaries sanction remuneration, Queensland trustees can ethically receive compensation while upholding fiduciary responsibilities and maintaining beneficiary trust.